← Bad Idea Database

Optimize everything

If you measure, squeeze, and systematize hard enough, you’ll get the best outcome.

Why smart people believed it
Optimization works astonishingly well in narrow domains — factories, ads, load times. Smart people generalize: if rigor helped *here*, it should help *everywhere*. Romance, taste, and slack look like waste on a spreadsheet.
What damage it caused
Over-optimization kills the romance. It strips the surplus meaning that makes a thing valuable to a buyer, a reader, or a partner. You get a locally efficient husk and wonder why demand fell.
Best critique
Jakob Greenfeld’s anti-optimization point lands: squeezing every variable can destroy the very quality you were trying to maximize. Romance isn’t inefficiency — it’s part of the value.
What to believe/do instead
Optimize the boring constraints. Leave room for taste, story, and play where value is created by surplus, not by squeezing.